Backloggd alternative and comparison
Both services help players track, rate and share games. Backloggd is the larger, established community; GamingList is a newer alternative built around detailed ratings, expressive profiles, library imports, achievements and a combined video-and-board-game identity.
Comparison last reviewed June 20, 2026. GamingList is our product; competitor strengths are included intentionally.
| Area | GamingList | Backloggd |
|---|---|---|
| Main game collection | Cross-platform list with seven current-state statuses | Collection tracking with played, playing, backlog and wishlist workflows |
| Ratings and reviews | 1–10 score, optional category ratings and written reviews | Game ratings, community averages and written reviews |
| Gaming history | Current list state, activity feed and completion dates | Detailed play sessions, time tracking and daily journaling |
| Custom lists | Ranked or unranked lists displayed on profiles | Public or private lists with ranking and progress options |
| Social features | Following feed, reactions, notifications and profile comparison | Following feed, reviews, lists and friend activity |
| Profile expression | Favorites, 3×3, About You card, stats, reviews and achievements | Collection, ratings, reviews, lists and journal activity |
| Library imports | Built-in Steam, Xbox and PlayStation library imports | No Steam, Xbox or PlayStation library import is advertised on Backloggd’s public feature overview |
| Other tabletop games | A separate board-game catalog and list | Primarily focused on video games |
Backloggd has a large existing player community, millions of ratings and reviews, and a detailed journal model for logging individual play sessions. Its public lists and established social activity are meaningful advantages.
GamingList emphasizes faster bulk maintenance, seven distinct backlog statuses, 1–10 score diamonds, genre-aware sub-ratings, Steam, Xbox and PlayStation imports, profile comparison, achievement views and more visual profile customization.
Choose based on the habit you want to maintain. If session-by-session journaling and a mature community matter most, Backloggd has a clear head start. If you want a highly visual personal gaming identity, detailed rating categories, imports and faster status updates, GamingList offers a different workflow worth testing.
No. Both products solve the same broad problem, but GamingList has its own list statuses, score diamonds, rating categories, profile cards, achievement views, comparison tools and board-game section.
Backloggd is a strong choice for players who value a large established community, detailed play-session journaling and years of public reviews and lists.
GamingList is worth trying if you want detailed 1–10 ratings, highly personal profiles, Steam, Xbox or PlayStation imports, achievement views, profile comparisons, or video and board-game tracking under one account.
Yes. A tracker becomes useful only when its workflow fits you. Try adding a representative group of games and compare how quickly you can update statuses, ratings and profile information.
Add a few games, try Quick rate and build the profile you would actually want to share.